luglio 2024

Ranking All the X-Men Movies from Best to Worst

🟣 Content Overview :

Deadpool & Wolverine will bring Hugh Jackman's Logan into the MCU on July 26.
X-Men Origins: Wolverine is criticized for its poor portrayal of Deadpool.
X-Men: Apocalypse failed to capitalize on the success of Days of Future Past.
Dark Phoenix is considered a misfire in adapting an iconic storyline.
The New Mutants struggled due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Why This Under-The-Radar AAA Title Is More Than Just A Far Cry Clone

By Kenneth Shepard, John Walker, and Ethan Gach

Published Tuesday 4:00 PM

We may earn a commission from links on this page

Deadpool & Wolverine is set to bring Hugh Jackman's Logan and several other members of the Fox X-Men movies into the Marvel Cinematic Universe on July 26.

With such a big moment in superhero movie history upon us, we figured what better time than the present to look back at all the X-Men movies.

The franchises' ups and downs are so stark that comparing the worst movies to the best ones makes it hard to believe any of the same people were involved.

But let's run down the best and worst of the X-Men films.

X-Men Origins: Wolverine

The first swing at an X-Men prequel is so bad it has other movies within its franchise making fun of it to this day.

You think Deadpool & Wolverine isn't going to have at least a few gags referencing the catastrophic mess that was turning Ryan Reynolds' Deadpool into a mouthless superweapon?

While the poor treatment of Deadpool is one of the most memetic things about X-Men Origins: Wolverine, that's hardly the movie's only issue.

Its plodding focuses on the parts of Wolverine's origins that are far less interesting than the stuff it glosses over.

For a movie that is supposed to be about Logan, it ends up having a bloated cast of characters that contribute very little.

Luckily, Jackman and audiences got a much tighter film focusing on Wolverine eight years later, but Origins: Wolverine is still a stain on a series that really needed a win.

X-Men: Apocalypse

After 2014's Days of Future Past set up the X-Men franchise for success, it really is a shame that Apocalypse fumbles the bag so hard.

The third film in the prequel series really feels like they were just making another one of these.

It attempts to repeat the successes of its predecessors with a painfully inferior take on the Days of Future Past's Quicksilver slo-mo rescue.

It introduces long-awaited characters like Storm and Psylocke only to do very little with them.

Also, what a waste of Oscar Isaac's talents as the titular big bad.

That's ultimately a pretty succinct encapsulation of Apocalypse. It's a movie with a lot of material to work with and talent on the screen that manages to devolve into the least imaginative or memorable versions of each of them.

Dark Phoenix

It's baffling to me that Dark Phoenix was as bad as it was when the last time the movies attempted this comic book storyline it was widely considered the film franchise's low point.

You'd think they'd be extra sure to get it right the second time around, but the fourth and final entry in X-Men's prequel movies feels like it's running on fumes.

If Apocalypse had no passion in it, Dark Phoenix is what happens when you signed a contract a decade ago and are legally required to make a movie.

Even the final scene between Fassbender and McAvoy is so muted compared to every other gut-wrenching and electric scene the two had together.

Who was this movie for if not the shareholders?

Shoutout to Sophie Turner who is doing her best to lead the film as Jean Grey while working with nothing from anyone else.

But Dark Phoenix is the second misfire of adapting an iconic X-Men storyline, and I'll be surprised if Marvel ever attempts it again even with the X-Men license back in its gaping maw.

Let Jean live a happy life in one continuity for heaven's sake.

X-Men: The Last Stand

The third movie in the X-Men franchise probably would have been a lot better had it not been for Superman Returns poaching a chunk of its creative team and cast.

But X-Men: The Last Stand still manages to feel like messing up a recipe when most of the ingredients are still sitting on the kitchen counter.

The Last Stand is widely derided for its senseless violence against the X-Men, killing off major characters for shock value rather than giving those moments real substance.

It lends credence to the internalized anti-mutant sentiment characters like Rogue had been unlearning for two movies, essentially unraveling everything the first two movies set up without a plan.

The Last Stand is so bad Days of Future Past's entire setup feels meant to write it out of existence. Thank god it did.

The New Mutants

The New Mutants, the horror film based on the X-Men, went under the radar for most people.

Part of it is because it opened during the early months of the COVID-19 pandemic and thus bombed at the box office.

Even with big names like Game of Thrones actor Maisie Williams, Furiosa lead Anya Taylor-Joy, and Stranger Things' Charlie Heaton, The New Mutants failed to draw in the same audience of even the worst X-Men movies.

But the often-forgotten film starring a group of mutants kept in a hospital and tormented by their worst fears had some compelling ideas.

It's not a great or even good merging of the superhero and horror genres, but it at the very least stands out above the sludge ranked below it.

Deadpool 2

Following Deadpool was a tough act.

A huge part of what the 2016 movie offered was its shocking nature.

It was an X-Men film that broke every rule, released at the height of the Marvel Cinematic Universe's success (no, it wasn't part of it, but regular audiences weren't researching such details), containing astonishing violence and wildly inappropriate jokes.

A sequel wasn't going to be able to rely on any of this given its audience were going in expecting it all.

The solution was not one outlandish comedy sequels have tended to use in the past. It tried harder.

It worked harder at its plot, its characters, and its pacing, creating a more nuanced setting in which it could mess around like a nine-year-old who'd learned a bunch of new curse words.

Relationships felt more meaningful, the emotional tone felt more earned. And yet it was still immensely stupid, violent, and gasp-inducing.

Still, it couldn't ever have the same impact as the original. To do that, it'd have to do something completely radical like, I dunno, break through the walls of reality to enter the MCU, dragging some of Marvel's most respected characters into its vortex of immature nonsense.

X-Men

The original X-Men movie is fascinating to watch as it harkens back to a simpler time for superhero films.

It's remarkably restrained as the genre has expanded into multiverses and using CG backgrounds for every shot.

Every scene feels intentional, building upon the mutant struggle and how each member of the X-Men factors into it.

The 2000 movie is refined instead of referential. It's campy instead of quippy.

Overall, it's just a really solid flick that understands what the X-Men are about.

And god, talk about a perfectly cast film. Patrick Stewart, Hugh Jackman, and Ian McKellen are some of, if not the best-casted superhero roles in the genre, and have solidified themselves into the DNA of their characters.

The Wolverine

2013 was a fascinating time for the X-Men franchise and comic book movies as a whole.

The MCU was in full swing with the first Avengers movie the year prior and a new cadence of at least two character-led blockbusters a year.

X-Men, meanwhile, was hobbling along. The introduction of a new generation of heroes with X-Men: First Class in 2011 had tried to wash away the disappointment of Last Stand and the underwhelming awkwardness of Origins, but the damage was still fresh.

So the fact that The Wolverine wasn't just a good X-Men movie but also a decent action flick in its own right felt like a big surprise at the time.

Broken physically and emotionally, Hugh Jackman's Wolverine finds himself in Japan powerless and on the run from the evil machinations of a corporate tycoon and old acquaintance.

Despite being based on comic arcs by Chris Claremont and Frank Miller, the spinoff movie was liberated from the constraints and demands of the larger X-Men films, letting it indulge in poignant character moments the larger series didn't always have time for amid world-ending showdowns.

The Wolverine whips between bucolic countryside and colorful city streets, showcases some incredible action sequences including one on a bullet train, and builds out the tormented hero's backstory in economical but effective ways.

It's the first time Jackman's Wolverine gets to explore the existential stakes of his mutant powers and the hundreds of years of baggage accumulated from them.

The Wolverine is ultimately a movie about death and what we owe one another and ourselves through our shared humanity and histories, and it manages to evoke those heavy themes without upstaging the fun and action of watching a guy with claws fight Yakuza.

Deadpool

The line between Ryan Reynolds the actor and Deadpool the character seems to become ever more narrow.

It's hard not to suspect he wears the suit around the house given how often it appears in the star's TikToks and promos and how Reynolds seems to have used it to exorcize all manner of aspects of his acting life.

But before 2016, the association between actor and comic book antihero was an outstandingly negative one—the disastrous Origins: Wolverine that's very lucky not to be at the bottom of this list.

Deadpool changed all that so damn fast.

Having been worked on for years by Reynolds and writers Rhett Reese and Paul Wernick, then later joined by director Tim Miller, the film became a labor of love and somehow escaped the studio interference that would usually flatten a project this outlandish and extreme.

The movie is rightly celebrated for its fourth-wall-breaking nature and the meta-commentary on both superhero cinema and its own intense violence and profanity, but if it were only that, it wouldn't be this high on the list.

It's also a film with pathos, with integrity, and with characters who feel grounded in a reality that its plot is not entitled to.

It's also a damn fine story and shot with the same visual flair Tim Miller brings to his incredible Love, Death & Robots animations.

Oh, and it's ludicrously funny.

X-Men: First Class

At a glance, it's easy to read X-Men: First Class as a cynical attempt to wring money out of a license after The Last Stand more or less scorched the earth you'd been building on.

But the prequel is one of the most concise depictions of the X-Men mythos that it felt like a proper reboot before the bad sequels came in and messed it all up.

First Class is all about the founding of the X-Men and Brotherhood of Mutants, with James McAvoy and Michael Fassbender taking on the younger roles of Professor X and Magneto.

Jennifer Lawrence also starred as Mystique before she was ever in The Hunger Games, and seeing a younger generation of actors bring new life into those roles made for a compelling origin story that could have easily felt trite and unnecessary.

The film is elevated by McAvoy and Fassbender's chemistry, who both had huge shoes to fill after Stewart and McKellen had become so embedded in the public eye as Professor X and Magneto.

They manage to capture the conflict, bright-eyed hope, and beaten-down cynicism that fuels the X-Men franchise, and even when the future movies fell short of First Class' promise, that fire never goes out.

X-Men: Days of Future Past

While First Class felt like a way to sidestep old mistakes and still capitalize on beloved characters, Days of Future Past is an excellent swing at fixing those mistakes so the franchise can move forward.

It didn't pay off as substantially worse movies followed, but the film's remixing of an iconic moment in X-Men's history is a truly effective use of the series' past to pave the way for its future.

The movie is essentially a crossover of X-Men movies new and old, with Jackman's Wolverine at the center.

During an apocalyptic moment in mutant history, Logan goes back in time to warn the First Class versions of the X-Men of the creation of the sentinels, only to find them in a state of disarray and McAvoy's Professor X in need of some schooling himself.

It's X-Men at its most melodramatic, filled with some of the series' best depictions of the mutant struggle.

McAvoy, Fassbender, and Lawrence give their best performances in what should have solidified them alongside their predecessors in these roles.

It's a shame the films that followed failed to capitalize on its successes.